Skip to main content

All the Bloody Shakespeare - Troilus and Cressida

 Troilus and Cressida


Falling down a hole with your legs chopped off feels like reading this play.


Close friends get to call it TC. It’s a bit of a weird title for the play because the eponymous lovers barely get a look in on the thing. Their entire story is this, Troilus falls in love with Cressida, then sees her flirting with Diomedes and gets hurt feelings. That’s literally the whole thing, let’s try not to think about it. Troilus isn't even on the side we're supposed to sympathise with.

You can see some obvious influence from Chaucer’s Troilus and Criseyde, and a huge influence from Seneca’s Trojan Women (yes, I can justify this statement, come at me). And what comes out is something not quite as good as either. However, the most obvious influence that Shakespeare draws on is Star Wars: The Phantom Menace.

The play starts out with a lot of exposition, and I do mean a lot! We’re talking three acts almost entirely given over to background information, political posturing and a few clumsy gags performed by Jar Jar Theristes. The Greeks and the Troyans (Shakespeare doesn’t know the correct word is Trojans, what an idiot!) have been at war for ages and it’s getting really old. Yoda isn’t in it but there are some of the greatest heroes and fighters in the history of the world gathered together at the brink of a great battle: Hector, Achilles, Ajax, Ulysses (that one is on Seneca), Aeneas, Priam and Menelaus (who isn’t mad but is in fact Spartan). And what way to better use these action heroes than to have them engaging in extended discussions and reading letters. The Greeks want the Greeks to win and the Troyans want the Troyans to win and because they’re so equally matched, it’s a bit of a stalemate. The narrative favours the Greeks so you can think of them as The Rebels, but it’s a very stupid war so morality doesn’t come into it much.

What isn’t helping is that the Greek’s best fighter Achilles is more interested in staying in his tent with his “friend” Patroclus than he is in winning the war. There is no direct statement that Achilles and Patroclus are lovers, but they get a better love story than Troilus and Cressida do. They sulk, they hide away and when Patroclus is killed by Hector, Achilles goes on a rampage and brings us to the best part of the play, Act Five.
It is a love that dare not speak its name.

Act Five is a riot. Literally. Shakespeare packs as much action as he can into the last section of the play, presumably in the assumption that if you end on a high note - the big fight then everything will be okay. It is the exact same strategy George Lucas picked when writing the Phantom Menace - endless politics and bureaucracy then a bit of Darth Maul to perk it all up. If Shakespeare .had been paying attention when he watched the prequels he might have avoided falling into the same trap (or he might at least have added a podrace to break it up a bit). In this section Hector is taking the place of Darth Maul - in that he is the best fighter and hands down the most interesting character. Much like the Phantom Menace it is not a fair fight. Hector has finished fighting for the day and is just getting into his pyjamas when Achilles and his gang of merry rampagers surround him and stab him up. This is much less heroic than the usual one on one portrayal of this fight in which Achilles comes off as heroic, there is no remedption for the Achilles character - he starts out a whiny turd and he wins his battle as a whiny turd. Which, for a heroic epic is not particularly gratifying. It would be like having the hero of Phantom Menace lose when fighting two on one and then pulling a "sand in the eyes" trick. It's just not a satisfying ending. It certainly doesn't justify all of the boring

So what becomes of Troillus and his beloved Cressida? They are, after all, supposed to be what the play is about it. Well, not much. When she leaves him for Diomedes he gets a bit sad. It's rubbish, this whole play is rubbish and a waste of your time. There is no other circumstance under which you will hear me say this but you would be better off watching the Phantom Menace. I hated this play so much, that I haven't been able to read another of his plays for sixth months.

2/5 - It's not a tragedy, it's not funny, it's not interesting. Get it together Shakey.
.

Comments

Post a Comment

Popular posts from this blog

All the Bloody Shakespeare: Love's Labour 's Lost

Imagine this four times over but with letters instead of conversations and Elizabethan hygiene standards. I was quite excited to read Love's Labour's Lost, it starts really well.  The king and his three mates all swear off women for three years to pursue academic interests and higher purposes.  Oh, and the king makes it law that everyone else has to do the same for ease of plot development.  It's all going well until a princess / potential queen shows up with her exactly three friends. There's a lot of potential here, and we see an immediate step up in terms of the quality of writing.  You know those nut jobs who think all Shakespeare's plays were written by different people? Well, I almost thought they had a point for a minute.  Almost every phrase the king utters is profound and well-composed.  This can't be written by the same bloke that wrote Two Gentlemen of Verona, I erroneously posited. Then we get Costard (a clown).  Costard has already broken ...
Post a Comment
Read more

All The Bloody Shakespeare - As You Like It

I think you ought to know, I'm feeling very depressed. As You Like It is Shakespeare doing the equivalent of a clip show. The whole play is filled with the kinds of things that show up in his earlier comedies. We have: • Brothers at odds with each other. • An intelligent female cross-dresser • A clown (Touchstone) making sheep jokes. • Multiple couples in minor confusions. • A Greek god inexplicably showing up. • Lots and lots of weddings. That said, it's much more polished than his earlier plays. The main plot is slow to start and most of the comedy comes from Orlando still be attracted to the woman he loves when she's dressed as a male shepherd. This is also the root of most of the sheep jokes. As You Like It has one thing that's new to Shakespeare, and that's Jaques. Whilst all the bog-standard rom-com stuff is happening, Jaques' only role in the play is to stand back and moan about how rubbish it all is. Jaques is a mixture of Marvin the Paranoi...
Post a Comment
Read more

Going to work is just awful

See, Bukowski gets it. I've just seen the #thingsIwillmissaboutlockdownhashtag trending.  So, I'll say this, I will miss not having to go to work. Look, I know people have it bad.   This Covid-19 thing is kicking the world’s economy right in the ass and taking down a lot of good people, both physically and financially.   And yes, this post is coming from a place of privilege; because, if I were about to miss a meal I know I’d be happy to get back to work.   Over the years, I’ve done some pretty humiliating stuff to make ends meet: from cleaning bottles of piss left by workmen on construction sites to lining up at an agency at 4am in the hope they might send me out for the day.   Thankfully, that’s all a while behind me, and right now, in a usual year, I would be marking exams for 14 hours a day seven days a week to top up my meagre teaching wage. So, let’s be honest, work is shit.   The average person with an average job, on average, earns below the a...
Post a Comment
Read more